Comparisons between Tears of the Kingdom (TOTK) and Breath of the Wild (BOTW) were inevitable. The two games take place in a nearly identical version of Hyrule. Maybe even more importantly, both games are on the Nintendo Switch. This may be the most important aspect of comparing the two games. Oftentimes it is very difficult to compare games across generations of consoles because the technology improves so much with each new generation. If I take a step backwards from comparing these two games and list my top 3 (the proverbial podium) favorite Zelda games, in no particular order they are A Link to the Past, Twilight Princess, and Breath of the Wild. Each of these games comes from a different console generation, so it is difficult to say that A Link to the Past is better than Twilight Princess. This isn't the case for TOTK and BOTW, so direct comparisons are easier. After playing BOTW for around 200 hours, and TOTK for around 100 hours, let's dive into my thoughts on the two games.
I played both games the same way. I focused on the main story quests first, and then after I "finished the game" by seeing the credits role, I focused on the side quests. In BOTW, I found and finished all 120 shrines, and did the majority of the side quests and DLC. In TOTK, I am currently in the process of locating and finishing all of the shrines. I plan to focus on the side quests afterwards. With both games taking place in essentially the same version of Hyrule, the game looks and feels very similar. And yet, despite how good BOTW is and was, TOTK somehow improves on nearly every aspect of the game.
To emphasize just how good TOTK is, let me list the various aspects of the game and which game is better in each category. The plot: TOTK. In fact, Tears has one of the better plots of any Zelda game and one of the more memorable endings to any game in the recent past. BOTW's plot is fine, but so much is prefaced on events that happened 100 years prior to the events of BOTW that it feels a bit distant. TOTK builds on the events of BOTW, and the aftermath is quite visible as you traverse Hyrule Kingdom. You have to look no further than the massive floating Hyrule Castle to be reminded of the Uprising.
Similar to the plot is the castles/temples: TOTK takes the prize here as well. The Divine Beasts of BOTW and their leaders were too similar and honestly not that memorable. When I started the Regional Phenomena main quest in TOTK and traveled to Rito village, I remember thinking about how epic the journey to the floating ship creating the storm over Rito was. And while the stage itself felt a lot like the Divine Beasts, the boss battle was absolutely epic as well. In the grand scheme of Zelda games, both games rank lower in this category, but between the two no question TOTK wins in this category as well.
I cannot tell a difference in the graphics between the two games, and both games have great soundtracks, albeit similar. I'm calling a draw in these two categories. Same for the controls. TOTK does suffer from more frequent frame rate drops than BOTW. You can tell that the Switch is pushed to its limits to run this game. It is an amazing feat that Nintendo was able to get this game to run on 6 year old hardware that wasn't exactly cutting edge when it was originally released. I should also point out that although I've said a couple of times that both games take place in similar versions of Hyrule, this is only partially true. The surface of Hyrule is essentially the same, but TOTK adds the depths, which is like a large cavern under Hyrule that doubles the size of the map. As if this wasn't enough, there are also numerous sky islands to visit above Hyrule, so the map in TOTK is actually quite a bit bigger than BOTW's Hyrule.
I was playing BOTW the other day, helping one of my daughters progress in her game. As I was working on a shrine puzzle, I found my self wishing I could ascend like you can in TOTK. With all of the game enhancements found in TOTK, I think it would be a bit hard to go back and replay BOTW. With all of the aforementioned evidence, I don't think there is any question that TOTK is the better game. The bigger question is will TOTK replace BOTW on my podium. While I think there is some merit to the fact that BOTW was first and more revolutionary, if push comes to shove I would replace it with TOTK on my podium. For the time being, however, I'm going to let them share the spot on the podium. BOTW is a fantastic game, and somehow Nintendo managed to make TOTK better in nearly every category.