Year Released: 2007
IGN Score: 9.7

With the release date of Super Mario Galaxy 2 revealed last week, I thought it would be an appropriate time to discuss my thoughts on the first Mario Galaxy. Mario is one of my all-time favorite gaming series, and Galaxy, while on the surface seems to be a very unique Mario experience, when you get to its roots it is basically the exact same game wrapped in a different package. This is the first time I have played a Mario game since 1996's Super Mario 64 (has it been that long??), which I consider to be both the greatest Mario and launch game ever. Quickly, I think Galaxy is pretty terrific, though I don't give it the praise a lot of critics do. There are a few things that prevent this game from topping Mario 64.
When I first played Galaxy I didn't really like it too much. I thought the whole concept was over the top and weird and I just didn't understand why everyone thought the game was so great. My attitude changed when I read the IGN review comparing Galaxy to Mario 64. It was at that time that I realized that the two games are exactly the same. Mario is in a confined space (castle vs space station) and enters different rooms within that confined space which magically take him to different lands. Oh yeah, and he is chasing stars again, the exact same concept seen in Mario 64. The other thing that bothered me from the beginning was the lack of any real story or character development other than rescue Peach from Bowser. Modern video games have evolved so much that it was difficult for me to remember even playing a game without plot progression and story twists. I had to remind myself that this game was born in the 1980s, and that at its core was a run and jump timing game and that has changed very little since the very first Super Mario Brothers on the NES. Actually, this game tries to incorporate a story probably more than any other Mario game before it, but frankly I found the story to be very odd and even a little bit creepy. Thankfully the story basically played no part in the progression of the game and you could choose to ignore it if you wanted to, which is what I did.
I was able to put those two major complaints behind me, and I am glad, because once I got into the game a bit I discovered a fantastic game. Nintendo doesn't shy away from the fact that this game is just like the old ones, and in fact utilizes almost all aspects from old games in Galaxy, including the music and numerous villains. I've mentioned before that I am a huge fan of video game nostalgia, and it is quite satisfying to arrive at a galaxy to be greeted by music from Mario 3.
Even more important than the nostalgia are all of the wonderful galaxies/stages seen in the game. Every galaxy is unique and wonderfully done. You never know what you are getting into when you fly to a galaxy for the first time, but everyone of them was a lot of fun. To be honest, I am kind of over the whole rescue Peach from Bowser thing, but there is something about acquiring those stars - its like video game crack - that keeps me coming back for more. And none of the stages disappointed in terms of fun on my quest to get the stars.
I do have a couple of complaints. One is minor and the other is kind of major. The minor point is that the game is very childish. Now I realize this is Mario and not Grand Theft Auto, and that the game is made for kids, but I think this game went a little much in the childish direction to the point of being kind of annoying. Mario 64 was for kids too and its theme wasn't nearly as annoying as this game's theme. The other complaint is that I think this game is plagued by awkward camera angles that frequently make it difficult to time your jumps correctly. That combined with the fact that some of the planets have odd gravitational forces makes dying very easy on this game. This might not make a whole lot of sense unless you play the game as it is hard to explain. Or it could just be that I suck at video games.
Overall Galaxy is a very good game, and a must own for any Wii owner. I think the IGN rating is a little high. I probably would have given it more like a 9.0 than a 9.7. I don't think it is better than Mario 64, and I don't think it's the best Wii game either (don't even get me started on how fantastic I thought Twilight Princess was, despite the dumb title), but everyone is entitled to their own opinion.
Check in Tuesday when I explain how Mario Galaxy (and Twilight Princess) ruined the Wii for me.
PS - Sarah really loved all of the toadstools roaming around the various galaxies!






