The hosts of the "new" The Grand Tour have a nearly impossible task. They have to replace three very well liked and long term hosts of the original The Grand Tour and Top Gear. It is difficult enough to replace one host, but to find three who are not only liked individually but work well together is a massive challenge. It's similar to replacing members of the Beetles. You can't just replace John and Paul and except there to be no hiccups and for no one to notice. Yet, here we are, with Jeremy, James, and Richard not getting any younger and calling it a career on the best TV show ever made, we find ourselves in this situation of needing new hosts to carry on. I really thought once the original trio retired that Amazon would retire the show. The BBC tried to carry on with Top Gear after the trio left, and did so for a few years before shutting the show down in 2023 (though apparently it has been announced that the show is returning in the future). Instead of shutting down the show, however, Amazon found three new hosts to carry on. I would've quit watching the show at this point, but I came across a couple of decent reviews so I decided to give it a chance and watched the first season.
I had never heard of any of the new hosts. Not that this matters, I suppose, because I had not heard of any of the original trio members either until I started watching Top Gear. James and Thomas are Canadian motoring journalist, popular for a YouTube channel they run called Throttle House. Francis is a social media personality & train enthusiast, popular for his trainspotting videos of all things. The season features brief appearances from the original trio, including a scene where Jeremy tells them to "Have fun. And don't f*ck this up." which is both funny and such a Jeremy thing to say. Generally, other than these appearances, the show moves forward trying to stand on its own two feet and not rely too heavily on its past.
The reviews I read said the new season was "decent" and I'd give it the same review. Overall the show is the same, following the same format as before. I generally liked the new hosts, and applaud them for being themselves and not trying too hard to emulate the original trio. At times they were a little too kind, I thought, both to each other and regarding the results of their cars/tests. This was especially true for James and Thomas. Francis was easily the most risky pick as a new host, and I think the risk paid off. He was easily the most unpredictable regarding what car he picked and how he approached the challenges, and brought a ton of knowledge to the show for someone famous for watching trains. Though a bit awkward at times, his presence spiced things up a bit compared to the much safer picks of Thomas and James. Overall, I think that the new hosts established a good foundation for what the new version of the show will look like, and this new trio should continue to gel in subsequent seasons. I'll plan on watching season 2, as long as I have access to Amazon Prime. In the meantime, I'm wrapping up the three episode The Not Very Grand Tour where the original trio do a last hurrah in the nursing home, highlighting scenes from previous The Grand Tour episodes.


